What is a drawing? Jerwood Drawing Prize 2012

Ask twenty people what a drawing is and I will bet you that at least half of them will mutter something about a pencil and paper, a few more might add charcoal, graphite, crayons or ink; one of them a pedant with access to Wikepedia might explain that it was two dimensional mark making involving transferring a small amount of the drawing medium onto a surface.

I have been pondering about the nature of drawing ever since seeing the exhibition of winners of the 2012 Jerwood Drawing Prize, currently showing at the Jerwood Gallery in Hastings It comprises 78 works from 73 artists which have been whittled down by the judging committee from a total field of nearly 3,000 works. Not quite the task facing the RA Summer Exhibition selection committee but still difficult. I don’t know how the panel defined drawing and whether they took the view that if an artist considered the work a drawing then that is what it was. Works of pencil on paper appeared to be in the minority;  they were certainly not all two dimensional; there was film, there was at least one photograph; there was light; there was what I might have described as a painting. There was collage.  On the whole I agreed they counted but didn’t anybody on the committee say “hang on; that is not a drawing”  about the festive hat or the little pile of pebbles (watch out for that one; my husband demonstrated twice how easy it is to trip over it ).

But these are quibbles; it is a remarkably rewarding exhibition and unlike the RA Summer Exhibition, the pieces  work well together and feel contemporary. The standard is also extraordinarily high. Pleasingly, I was in complete agreement about the overall winner. This was a short animated video by Karolina Glusiec who is only 26 and comes from Poland. It is an exceptional  work which reflects on the memory of a place that was once really well known but which has changed.  It explores nostalgic feelings for a place without being sentimental;  it is also about the nature of memory and imagination. The commentary, which is spoken by a male voice who delivers it with just the right matter of fact tone, is poetic in itself. The words and images really work together. What is interesting is the way that the words describes a scene, which is illustrated by the pictures but which make you imagine something else. Just six minutes long it includes  some striking scenes – a woman with her hair blowing in the wind created by a passing train, people going to a factory and the way that the drawing dissolves into chaos and then re-emerges.  Still photographs in no way do it justice; if you have a chance, do go and see it.

A sketched woman stands looking out of a window in a still from the prize winning video
Still from the Jerwood Drawing Prize winning entry Velocity
A sketched man smoking a cigarette
Still from Velocity winner of the 2012 Jerwood Drawing Prize

Of the other prize winners I also particularly liked the entry Waiting by Min Kim, who won in the student category. It comprises 834 pieces of paper on which a balloon has been drawn in thick graphite. You cannot leaf through the pages but you can sense that each carries an identical drawing by the graphite dust which is visible on the side of the pages. I really liked the contrast between the qualities of airiness that we associate with a balloon and the heaviness of the way that Min Kim has thickly applied the graphite, digging into the paper. Although the balloon is such a simple shape and, because it is black, a silhouette, you also notice the detail of the way that the balloon is knotted. Min Kim has explained that the idea came to her as a balloon filled with a deep black breath –  a striking concept.

There are two images of balloons on sheets of paper which carry identical images
Waiting: student prize winning entry by Mim Kim.

There were so many other entries that I  liked I am certain I will notice others when I go back. Here are a some of the works which I felt were exceptional and which give an idea of the variety.

1. Carl Randall: Notes on the Tokyo Underground

Two images of people  sitting on the Tokyo tube
Carl Randall Notes from the Tokyo Underground
Four separate drawings by Carl Randal of people on the Tokyo Tube
More faces on the Tokyo Tube

I like thinking of Carl Randall sitting on the Tokyo Underground; notebook open, sketching away.  Displayed together are 72 drawings, many of them humorous: some were missing a leg, one had four hands, presumably in both cases because the subject kept moving. One was looking at a mobile phone – would it work? All of them appeared to capture the character of of the person and together gave a real impression of the atmosphere on the Tokyo tube.

2. Judith Alder: An unhealthy obsession

An open artist's notepad on which biro marks have been made across the crease of the pages
An unhealthy obsession work by Judith Alder

I wonder whether artists who favour drawing tend to be more obsessional than other artists. There was certainly signs of obsession in the exhibition: – in Min Kim’s Waiting, in Ruth Simons’ Phenotype.  This particular work by Judith Alder seemed to sum it up perfectly; it comprises certainly hundreds, probably thousands of black biro strokes across the open pages of an artists book. It seems amazing that a biro could produce a work of such delicacy. It was such a simple concept but quite extraordinarily  effective. Each stroke appeared to resemble a hair and the effect of the fold produced something which resembled the pubic area. Alder describes her work as about “The chaos of uncontrolled and unwanted growths”

3, Ruth Simons: Phenotype

A sheet of graph paper on which near identical rubbings have been created
Detail from Ruth Simons’ work: Phenotype

I counted the number of these little pencil rubbings by Ruth Simons made on red coloured graph paper; I think there were 76 vertical squares and 56 horizontal squares making 4256 all together. I kept losing my place on the counting and the idea of actually producing 4246 images is mind-blowing; imagine having got to 2123 and you are only half way there. Incidentally a phenotype, for those who like me feel they sort of know what it is but couldn’t actually define it for somebody, is the composite of an organism’s observable characteristics or traits. These little rubbings reminded me of samples growing in their separate agar jars.

4. Kaspar Pincis: 4 tent pegs

Four tent pegs made out of balsa wood displayed in a glass cabinet
Kaspar Pincis: 4 Tent Pegs

Strictly I don’t think this is a drawing; these are not clever marks on a piece of paper; they are clever facsimiles of tent pegs made out of balsa wood gesso and graphite powder. Ok, you can argue it like this; they have graphite on them; graphite is used for drawing, therefore this is a drawing. This is actually an excellent example of a false syllogism.  They are not drawings they are model tent pegs. Having got that little rant over, I was pleased they were included as I really liked them, though I found it hard to explain to myself why. It was something about the shininess and being other than what they appeared.  I looked up Kapar Pincis’ website and he can actually draw; he also makes a lot of tent pegs. He was one of the few artists who had two works included in the exhibition; I also liked the other one created with a typewriter on newsprint:  As if you could kill time without injuring eternity.

5. Tanya Wood: Pillow

Drawing of a pillow by Tanya Wood
Tanya Wood: Pillow

Proving that drawing as a skill is not dead, is this work by Tanya Wood. It  is not a conceptual piece but it is a remarkable drawing of a pillow which is perhaps one of the most featureless objects you can imagine but it is perfectly captured.; you can almost feel its pillowyness. It is not just any pillow; it is that particular pillow – a portrait of a pillow which starts you thinking about the heads that have lain on it and made it that way.

Stefan Gant: Crossing the Line

A still shot from a video showing a hand drawing a line; it illustrates the points made by an American pastor
Stefan Gant: Crossing the Line

Crossing the Line is a remarkably funny video which illustrates the verbal mannerisms of as American pastor discussing marriage, commitment and prayer. As you can see he speaks about crossing the line a lot and every time he does, the hand demonstrates by crossing the drawn line on the piece of paper. I laughed out loud.

7. Richard Galloway: Dolor

a detail from Richard Galloway's lino cut  showing stylised London scene
Detail from Dolor by Richard Galloway

Richard Galloway’s Dolor is a  hand painted lino cut and quite exceptionally detailed; it is an imagined London landscape where all human life is present. The politics may not be particularly subtle; a loan shark offers loans while behind the wall a man hangs himself. Even so it is hugely lively and repays studying as you notice more and more details.

Ishai Rimmer: in the kitchen

A drawing of a man sitting in the kitchen clothed only in boxer shorts
In the Kitchen: drawing by Ishai Rimmer

You could hardly miss this large bold self portrait by Ishai Rimmer drawn, and in this case I do agree it is drawn, in household paint on paper. There is something about the size, the apparent simplicity of the image; the washing machine the oven. It is unmistakably now.

Footnote . I have just read Lisa Milroy’s account of the judging process and the entries they considered. Apparently there was a recurrent theme and that was hair -“By the end of the judging process, we had looked at dozens of drawings of heads of hair, chest hair, tufts of hair, beards, single strands of hair, wigs, and real hair sandwiched between glass or glued to paper in suggestive swirls or spelling out words.” she wrote . Perhaps unsurprisingly after seeing so many a drawings, not a single hair got  through – unless it did and  I missed it. Though Judith Alder’s work reminded me of hair, it was not clear it was intended. It seems a pity – no hair; on the other hand I was really glad they didn’t include any of the dogs or squirrels.

The Jerwood Drawing Prize will be showing at the Jerwood Gallery Hastings until January 6 2013.

2 thoughts on “What is a drawing? Jerwood Drawing Prize 2012

  1. Seems to be a degree of negative rationalising going on here with limited visual skills, and a disproportionate reliance on conceptual approaches. Describing an idea is open to compromise on confronting challenging visual problem’s and illusions..

  2. Pingback: References – Drawing: A 'Whisper or Roar'

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s